Add your promotional text...

When Grace Isn’t Mutual: The One-Way Mirror of Criticism

RELATIONSHIPSSPIRITUAL GROWTH

Deborah Colleen Rose

5/14/20253 min read

You know what I’ve had enough of?

People treating you like a piece of IKEA furniture they can "fix" with an Allen wrench and some unsolicited feedback—without once looking at the cracked legs on their own damn coffee table.

They come to you like spiritual inspectors with a clipboard in one hand and a blindfold over the other eye, ready to tell you everything you need to change—about your tone, your timing, your tears, your truth.
As if your personality came with a customer service number and they're calling to file a complaint.

And you sit there, blinking, thinking:
Do you even realize what I overlook in you on a daily basis?

The way you interrupt people like you're being timed by a game show buzzer.
The emotional black holes you create when you ghost instead of communicate.
The way you say, “I’m just being honest,” as if that’s a hall pass for cruelty.

But I’ve let it slide. Over and over.
Because I know people are complicated. I believe in mercy. I believe in giving others the grace I hope someone gives me on the days when I’m a walking apology in search of a reset.

But when grace isn’t mutual—when it becomes a one-way mirror where they’re always doing the watching, the judging, the dissecting, while you just keep absorbing and adjusting—
you’ve got to ask yourself: Is this a relationship or a performance?

Some People Don’t Want Growth. They Want Comfort.

A lot of people don’t want to grow.
They don’t want to be stretched, stirred, or spiritually poked.

They want to keep their comfort intact, their worldview undisturbed, and their habits unexamined.
They don’t want to be challenged—they want to be coddled.
They don’t want transformation—they want insulation.
They don’t want truth if it makes noise.

They want you polite, predictable, and quiet enough to not wake the sleeping parts of themselves they’ve worked hard to ignore.

You make them uncomfortable, not because you’re wrong, but because you’re real.
Because you say what they won’t.
Because you’re willing to look in the mirror and ask, “What part of this is mine?”—and they haven’t done that since AOL dial-up.

“You’re Too Much” Often Means “You’re Too Honest for My Comfort”

When they say, “You’re too much,”
what they usually mean is,
“You’re too much for me to handle without having to grow.”

But your job isn't to downplay your brilliance so someone else can avoid sunglasses.

Your job is not to make yourself smaller to fit inside someone’s emotionally budgeted comfort zone.

And you know what? Let’s talk about discomfort.

Discomfort is not always a red flag.
Sometimes, it’s a flare sent up by the Holy Spirit saying:
“Pay attention here—there’s healing that wants to happen.”

If something I say makes you squirm, maybe it’s not because I’m being cruel.
Maybe it’s because it’s pressing on a bruise you’ve been pretending wasn’t there.

The mature response isn’t, “You need to change so I don’t feel this way.”
It’s, “Why do I feel this way? And what’s mine to own?”

Real Relationships Require Mutuality

That’s the real work. The holy work.
And let me be clear: I’m still in that work myself.
I know I’ve got places that need sanding and pruning.
I don’t walk around thinking I’m a finished product.

But if you’re going to come at me with your edit list,
be prepared to accept mine, too.

Not in a tit-for-tat way—but in a covenant of mutual growth.
Otherwise, don’t hand me your critique like it's holy scripture when you haven’t even read your own chapters.

Real connection sounds like:

  • “Hey, this hit me weird—can we talk about it?”

  • “I know I’ve got stuff too. What have you been holding back?”

  • “I want to understand, not just be comfortable.”

It’s grace given and grace returned.
It’s a dance where both people learn new steps,
not one person forced to sit still while the other stomps around to their own rhythm.

Truth Without Gloss: The Cost of Being Real

And if the way I speak—the rough edges, the raw truth, the lack of verbal sugar-coating—rubs you wrong?

That might say more about how you've been trained to accept false kindness than it does about my delivery.

Manners can be a beautiful thing when they’re rooted in love and consideration.

But let’s not kid ourselves:
Sometimes manners are just camouflage.

A way to keep things polite but distant.
Nice but numb.
Controlled but cold.

Sometimes people prefer:

  • etiquette over intimacy,

  • small talk over soul talk,

  • and the illusion of peace over the work of real connection.

Because surface-level kindness asks nothing of them.
It doesn’t press on their sore spots.
It doesn’t invite them into transformation.

It just helps them feel comfortable enough to keep pretending everything’s fine.

But I wasn’t called to be a wallpaper version of myself just so you can keep your decor intact.

So shine.
Speak.
Shake the dust.

And if it rattles them?

Let it.

Maybe it’s the first time their soul has heard an alarm worth waking up to.